Pudaier Waterproof Microblading Eyebrow Pencil Review: Is It Worth It?

I bought the Pudaier Waterproof Microblading Eyebrow Pencil in the two-pack because I liked the idea of having a quick way to fill in my brows without having to spend ages drawing and blending them. The four-tip design is supposed to create several tiny hair-like strokes at once, which sounded much easier than trying to draw every individual brow hair myself.

After using it, I can see why the design is appealing, but I also found that getting the advertised microbladed look takes a little more control than the product makes it seem.

Key Takeaways

• The four-prong tip makes filling sparse areas much faster.
• It can create convincing hair-like strokes when used lightly.
• The ink is quite pigmented, so pressing too hard can make the brows look darker and heavier than intended.
• The two-pack is convenient because I have a backup ready to go.
• It takes some practice to get the strokes going in the direction you want.
• The waterproof claim is one of the better features because the color does not immediately disappear.
• It works better for filling and defining than completely creating a new brow shape.
• I like it, but I would not call it completely foolproof.

What Is the Pudaier Waterproof Microblading Eyebrow Pencil?

The Pudaier Waterproof Microblading Eyebrow Pencil is actually more like a liquid eyebrow pen than a traditional pencil. It has a four-prong applicator designed to create several fine lines in one stroke, giving the brows the appearance of individual hairs.

Pudaier describes it as waterproof and smudge-resistant, with a buildable formula that can be layered for either a softer or more defined brow. The idea is basically to get that microbladed effect without actually committing to microblading.

I bought the two-pack, which gave me two pens rather than having to worry about replacing one immediately.

Why I Bought It

I wanted something that would make doing my brows quicker. I don’t mind filling in my eyebrows, but I don’t particularly enjoy sitting there trying to make both sides look identical. There is always that point where one brow looks good, and the other suddenly seems to have developed a completely different personality.

The four-tip design caught my attention because it looked like it could give me multiple little strokes at once instead of requiring me to painstakingly draw each one.

I also liked the idea of having something more natural-looking than simply filling my brows in with a solid block of pencil.

My Experience Using the Pudaier Eyebrow Pencil

The first thing I noticed was that the applicator is definitely different from a normal eyebrow pencil. Instead of one solid point, you have those tiny little prongs that are supposed to create several lines at once.

Once I figured out how much pressure to use, I actually found it pretty useful. The trick is not to press down heavily.

When I used a light hand and followed the direction of my actual brow hairs, I could get those little individual strokes that made my brows look fuller without immediately making them look drawn on. I particularly liked using it toward the thinner areas where I just needed a few extra hairs rather than filling in the entire brow.

The problem is that the pen can go from natural-looking to “I definitely drew my eyebrows on” surprisingly quickly if I get too heavy-handed.

That is something I had to learn because the four tips make it tempting to just drag the pen across the brow and expect everything to magically come together. It doesn’t quite work that way. If the strokes are too long, too dark or going in the wrong direction, they become much more obvious.

I also found that I had to pay attention to the angle of the pen. The whole point of the applicator is to imitate individual hairs, so the strokes need to follow the direction my brows naturally grow. If I just swipe horizontally because I’m in a hurry, the result looks much less convincing.

Once I got the hang of that, the application became much easier. I particularly like the pen for filling little gaps. Instead of colouring over the entire eyebrow, I can add a few strokes where the brow looks sparse and then leave the rest of the natural hair alone. That gives me a fuller appearance without making my eyebrows look like they have been stamped onto my face.

The waterproof aspect is also useful. I don’t want to spend time doing my brows only for a little sweat or accidental rubbing to erase half of one eyebrow. The formula does hold up better than I expected, although I still wouldn’t treat the word “waterproof” as meaning I can aggressively rub my face and expect everything to stay perfectly intact.

The two-pack was also a good decision for me. Having a second pen sitting around means I don’t have to immediately replace it when the first one eventually runs out or dries up. With a product like this, having a backup is actually more useful than it sounds because brow products are one of those things I don’t want to discover I have run out of when I’m already getting ready.

Does It Really Give a Microbladed Look?

It can, but I wouldn’t expect to pick it up for the first time and immediately create perfect microbladed brows. The product gives you the right basic tool because its multiple fine tips can create several hair-like lines in one movement. But the final result depends heavily on how you use it.

Light pressure, short strokes and following the direction of your natural hair make a huge difference. I also think it looks better when I use it to supplement my existing brows rather than trying to completely redraw them. Once you start covering large areas with repeated strokes, the lines become much more noticeable, and the result can start looking more like makeup than actual brow hairs.

For me, it works best as a filling and definition product.

What I Loved

The four-tip applicator is the reason I bought this product, and it is also the reason I ended up liking it.

It makes filling sparse areas noticeably quicker than using a regular pencil and trying to draw every little line separately.

I also like that I can build up the colour gradually. Starting lightly gives me more control, and I can always add another few strokes if an area still looks too sparse.

The two-pack is another plus because I like having a backup rather than buying one pen and immediately wondering how long it will last.

What I Didn’t Love

• The applicator takes some practice.
• Too much pressure can make the brows look darker and less natural.
• The strokes can look obvious if they are drawn in the wrong direction.
• It is easier to create natural-looking brows when filling sparse areas than when completely reshaping the brows.
• It isn’t quite as effortless as the microblading-style marketing makes it look.

Is the Pudaier Eyebrow Pencil Worth It?

For me, yes. I like the convenience of the four-tip design, and the two-pack makes the purchase more practical. It saves me time when I want my brows to look fuller without spending ages filling them in.

I just wouldn’t buy it expecting the pen to do all the work for me. There is still a little learning curve, and the more carefully I apply it, the better the result looks. Once I figured out the right pressure and direction, though, I found it much easier to work with.

Who I Think Will Love It

I think this is a good option if you:

• Have sparse areas you want to fill.
• Prefer hair-like brow strokes rather than a solid filled-in look.
• Want something quicker than manually drawing individual hairs.
• Like waterproof brow makeup.
• Want a backup product included in the same purchase.

Who Should Skip It

I would skip it if you prefer a traditional eyebrow pencil, powder or pomade and don’t want to spend any time getting used to a different applicator.

I also wouldn’t recommend it if you want something that can effortlessly redraw your entire brow shape. This works better with the brows you already have rather than completely replacing them.

Alternatives

• Pudaier Superfine Micro Stroking Detail Eyebrow Pen
• Pudaier Retractable Longwear Eyebrow Pencil
• Pudaier Perfect 2-in-1 Eyebrow & Hairline Powder Pen

Conclusion

The Pudaier Waterproof Microblading Eyebrow Pencil ended up being a useful little brow product for me, particularly because I bought the two-pack and don’t have to worry about being left with nothing when one runs out.

What I like most is the ability to fill sparse areas quickly while still keeping the brows looking relatively natural. The four-prong tip does make a difference, but it isn’t completely foolproof. I had to learn to use a light hand and follow the direction of my natural brow hairs instead of simply dragging the pen across my eyebrows.

Once I figured that out, I liked the result much more.

Would I buy it again?

Yes, especially as a two-pack. I like having something quick for filling in sparse areas, and this is easier for me than trying to create dozens of individual brow hairs with a normal pencil.

Would I recommend it?

Yes, with a small learning curve. It is not going to give you professionally microbladed brows with zero effort, but if you use light strokes and don’t go overboard, it can give you a much more natural-looking filled brow than simply colouring everything in.

Also read my similar review of the FaceLove Changing Foundation Stick